Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
DiscussionsAccessExcelInfoPathOutlookPowerPointPublisherWord
DirectoryUser Groups
Related Topics
Outlook ExpressInternet ExplorerWindowsMS Server ProductsMore Topics ...

MS Office Forum / Word / General MS Word Questions / July 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Change paper size; Word changes to invalid margins

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
OhioTech - 03 Jul 2006 19:21 GMT
Word 2002

Default paper size: 8.5 x 11
Margins: Top and bottom 1, Left and right 1.25

Change paper size to Custom 7 x 9

Message: One or more margins are set outside the printable area of the
page. Choose the Fix button to increase the appropriate margins.

Click Fix.

Word changed margins to Top 1, Bottom 9.5, Left 3.75, Right 3.75.
OK

Message: The settings you chose for the left and right margins, column
spacing, or paragraph indents are too large for the page width in some
sections.

Why did Word change to margins that are no good?
TF - 03 Jul 2006 22:30 GMT
This is almost certainly because the print driver does not support 7 x 9
paper size. It is Word interrogating the print driver that determines the
minimum margins and paper size permitted. Try a different printer (and
driver) and test to see if it works correctly.

Signature

Terry Farrell - Word MVP
http://word.mvps.org/

: Word 2002
:
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
:
: Why did Word change to margins that are no good?
OhioTech - 05 Jul 2006 03:21 GMT
Word is not helpful in these ways:
>Term "printable area" in message is not found in Word Help.
>Word did not provide way for user to get additional information.
>Word did not explain effect of clicking Ignore option.
>Word tells user to click Fix to resolve problem, but it does not resolve problem; instead
>Word changed margins to INVALID values for paper size of 7 x 9, then
>Word blames user for choosing bad values.

This is NOT user friendly!

I checked with the printer manual; it states custom sizes are OK; just load
paper on right side. I printed an Excel sheet on 7 x 9 paper. The printer
printed the info and advanced the paper thru. That's exactly what I expected.
If it can do this, I'd say the print driver supports 7 x 9 paper.

I wouldn't think that a paper size smaller than standard 8.5 x 11 should be
a problem. If the print driver supports 8.5 x 11, what's the problem with a
smaller size? The printed image starts at upper left corner as we see it on
screen, and transferred to actual paper as it is driven thru the printer.

I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
I'm greatly disappointed.

> This is almost certainly because the print driver does not support 7 x 9
> paper size. It is Word interrogating the print driver that determines the
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> :
> : Why did Word change to margins that are no good?
TF - 05 Jul 2006 10:58 GMT
I say again that this is not really a Word problem. I can certainly do
custom sizes smaller using a Canon printer driver. Maybe your printer driver
is corrupt or out of date. Check to see if there is a newer driver and then
delete and reinstall the driver.

Word has not change the margins to an invalid value off its own bat: it is
the printer driver that determines these settings and NOT Word. Where does
Word blame the user?

Surely IGNORE needs no definition. It means the same in any version of the
English Language.

Printable Area is defined as 'Area that is Printable'. Every printer (well
standard home/office printers) has a narrow unprintable area around the page
(unprintable border). Older InkJets had a huge unprintable area at the
bottom of the page, but usually the unprintable area these days is around
5mm all around the page.

If you want to print to the edge of a page, you need to go to a print shop
where they have printers that 'bleed' to the edges. (Many Photo Printers
have an option to print photo to the edges of special paper though.)

Terry

: Word is not helpful in these ways:
: >Term "printable area" in message is not found in Word Help.
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
: I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
: I'm greatly disappointed.
OhioTech - 05 Jul 2006 13:54 GMT
(See WORKAROUND at bottom)

Review the original problem:

Start Word, new document. Default paper size: 8.5 x 11
Margins: Top and bottom 1, Left and right 1.25

Change paper size to 7 x 9

Word shows message A: "One or more margins are set outside the printable
area of the page. Choose the Fix button to increase the appropriate margins."

$ Question 1: What is a "printable area"? Look in Word Help; it's Not Found.
Technical terms in messages should be defined in Help; this is a Word problem.
 
$ Question 2: What is the specific printable area in this case?
If Word determines this from the print driver, why can't Word display it to
me?  

$ Question 3: Which margin (shown for 8.5 x 11 doc) is "set outside" the
"printable area"?  If Word determines this from the print driver, why can't
Word tell me which margin is a problem?

I then clicked Fix, as Word told me to do.

Word changed the margins to: Top 1, Bottom 9.5, Left 3.75, Right 3.75.

$ Question 4: On a 7x9 document, how did Word calculate each of these
margins? Even a new user can see the Bottom, Left, and Right margins are
INVALID. Word approved the changes knowing the doc size, so it's another Word
problem.

After clicking OK, Word shows message B: "The settings you chose for the
left and right margins, column spacing, or paragraph indents are too large
for the page width in some sections."

$ Question 5: Why does Word blame me (the settings YOU chose) for changing
the margins?
I did not enter the new margins. The only other party here that I know about
is Word. Word told me to click Fix. As a new user, I know nothing about Word
interacting with print drivers.
A more accurate and helpful message is: "The current print driver has
determined a new Left margin value, which is invalid. For more information,
see Help under xxxxx."

$ Clicking on Ignore, and then entering data into doc, do Print preview, the
data is not there. Ignore evidently means more than simply ignore the
message.  

WORKAROUND

Lexmark Tech Support suggested this:
Go to Control Panel, Printers, Properties (of specific printer being used),
Printing Preferences, Paper Setup. Select Custom size, enter 7 x 9.

Repeat exercise in Word. Now I do not get message A.

Then I go back to Control Panel and change back to standard Letter (8.5 x
11).

Repeat exercise in Word. I still do not get message A.
In Word, change paper size to other custom sizes. No message A.

What has happened? It appears that going into Control Panel and specifying
7x9 custom size has told Word that ANY custom size is OK from now on (even
after Control Panel shows standard Letter again).

And I do not know how to make the problem occur again.
This also causes confusion!

I would like to get more information about the relationship between Print
driver, Control Panel, and Word. For example, did Control Panel change the
print driver? What exactly does Word consult to determine "printable area"
and valid margins? Is it not reasonable to want to understand the rules?

> I say again that this is not really a Word problem. I can certainly do
> custom sizes smaller using a Canon printer driver. Maybe your printer driver
[quoted text clipped - 48 lines]
> : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
> : I'm greatly disappointed.
TF - 05 Jul 2006 16:12 GMT
Word interrogates the printer driver. There is nowhere else it can gain this
information. If the printer driver provides the wrong information to Word,
Word will display the wrong information. This is not Word's fault.

The printable area (or specifically the non-printable areas should be in the
Printer's documentation (usually set out as the minimum margins).

The programming side of Word is not public knowledge, but as the printer
manufacturers are able (usually) to write drivers, they must be give the
necessary information. Word uses the data provided by the printer driver to
calculate not just page margins but how to layout the page for the attached
printer.

Terry Farrell

: (See WORKAROUND at bottom)
:
[quoted text clipped - 123 lines]
: > : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
: > : I'm greatly disappointed.
OhioTech - 05 Jul 2006 18:22 GMT
Evidently Word interrogates the settings in Control Panel also, cause that's
what I changed. Is that the same as what the Print Driver has? Who knows?

What I'm looking for is - what specific information did Word obtain in order
to change the margins as it did.

Example: Your manager asks for a 9" wrench. You ask your worker to get one
but he gives you a 12" wrench. Will you give the wrong tool to your manager,
or will you apply some Quality Assurance and tell the manager the wrong tool
has been presented to you?
If you do give the wrong tool to your manager, will he not say "You were
wrong in giving me this tool."?

This is what happened: The user requested 7 x 9 paper size.
Evidently the print driver information caused Word to think it needs these
margins:
Bottom 9.5, Left 3.75, Right 3.75.

Should Word know that a 9.5 margin is invalid on a document 9 inches high?
YES!
Word should apply QA and tell the user:
"The print driver has requested an invalid Bottom margin.
Please see xxxxx in Help for more information.".

And should not change margins to invalid values.

Not related to this forum: I write programs in VB.Net and am familiar with
various objects in Word. I have not investigated if the information that Word
obtains from Print Driver / Control Panel are objects that can be read. If a
print program is deployed to computers with various values in PD/CP, it seems
that the program should be able to read them and make appropriate decisions...

> Word interrogates the printer driver. There is nowhere else it can gain this
> information. If the printer driver provides the wrong information to Word,
[quoted text clipped - 164 lines]
> : > : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
> : > : I'm greatly disappointed.
stadtchemnitz@arcor.de - 06 Jul 2006 07:15 GMT
test

> Word interrogates the printer driver. There is nowhere else it can gain this
> information. If the printer driver provides the wrong information to Word,
[quoted text clipped - 164 lines]
> : > : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
> : > : I'm greatly disappointed.
JoAnn Paules [MVP] - 06 Jul 2006 14:00 GMT
Please stop this! If you need to test your system, there is a test newsgroup
specifically for this purpose.

Signature

JoAnn Paules
MVP Microsoft [Publisher]

> test
>
[quoted text clipped - 198 lines]
>> : > : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
>> : > : I'm greatly disappointed.
Suzanne S. Barnhill - 05 Jul 2006 16:19 GMT
The second error message you got often results from a glitch in the Columns
setting. Go to Format | Columns, click on the preset picture for One and
click OK. See if that resolves the issue.

Alternatively, if Word and your printer won't cooperate to print a specific
small paper size, the standard workaround is to set the document up on a
standard size (US Letter, for example), increasing the margins as required
to locate the print area on the paper area.

Signature

Suzanne S. Barnhill
Microsoft MVP (Word)
Words into Type
Fairhope, Alabama USA
Word MVP FAQ site: http://word.mvps.org
Email cannot be acknowledged; please post all follow-ups to the newsgroup so
all may benefit.

> (See WORKAROUND at bottom)
>
[quoted text clipped - 123 lines]
> > : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
> > : I'm greatly disappointed.
aalaan@tpg.com.au - 05 Jul 2006 20:26 GMT
Great detail. Agree with the sentiments. Hope you get the answer here.

> (See WORKAROUND at bottom)
>
[quoted text clipped - 148 lines]
>> : I would think this would be a "piece of cake" for Word.
>> : I'm greatly disappointed.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.